Detecting moving shadows: Algorithms and evaluation

Detecting moving shadows: Algorithms and evaluation

2003-07-01 | Andrea Prati, Member, IEEE, Ivana Mikic, Member, IEEE, Mohan M. Trivedi, Member, IEEE, Rita Cucchiara, Member, IEEE
The paper "Detecting Moving Shadows: Algorithms and Evaluation" by Andrea Prati, Ivana Mikic, Mohan M. Trivedi, and Rita Cucchiara, published in the IEEE Transactions on Pattern Analysis and Machine Intelligence, provides a comprehensive survey and evaluation of moving shadow detection algorithms. The authors classify these algorithms into four categories: statistical nonparametric (SNP), statistical parametric (SP), deterministic nonmodel-based (DNM1), and deterministic model-based (DNM2). They present a comparative empirical evaluation of four representative algorithms from these classes, using novel quantitative and qualitative metrics to assess their performance on a benchmark suite of indoor and outdoor video sequences. The evaluation metrics include detection and discrimination rates, scene and object independence, flexibility to shadow situations, and robustness to noise. The paper highlights the strengths and limitations of each approach and suggests that a pixel-based deterministic nonmodel-based approach (DNM1) performs best for general-purpose shadow detection systems with minimal assumptions. However, more specialized and assumptions-intensive approaches are recommended for specific environments or scenarios. The authors also discuss the limitations of using only image-derived information and suggest future directions, such as incorporating physically important independent variables to improve the accuracy of shadow detection algorithms.The paper "Detecting Moving Shadows: Algorithms and Evaluation" by Andrea Prati, Ivana Mikic, Mohan M. Trivedi, and Rita Cucchiara, published in the IEEE Transactions on Pattern Analysis and Machine Intelligence, provides a comprehensive survey and evaluation of moving shadow detection algorithms. The authors classify these algorithms into four categories: statistical nonparametric (SNP), statistical parametric (SP), deterministic nonmodel-based (DNM1), and deterministic model-based (DNM2). They present a comparative empirical evaluation of four representative algorithms from these classes, using novel quantitative and qualitative metrics to assess their performance on a benchmark suite of indoor and outdoor video sequences. The evaluation metrics include detection and discrimination rates, scene and object independence, flexibility to shadow situations, and robustness to noise. The paper highlights the strengths and limitations of each approach and suggests that a pixel-based deterministic nonmodel-based approach (DNM1) performs best for general-purpose shadow detection systems with minimal assumptions. However, more specialized and assumptions-intensive approaches are recommended for specific environments or scenarios. The authors also discuss the limitations of using only image-derived information and suggest future directions, such as incorporating physically important independent variables to improve the accuracy of shadow detection algorithms.
Reach us at info@study.space