2024 | FLORENCIA TORCHE, JASON FLETCHER, AND JENNIE E. BRAND
The article "Disparate Effects of Disruptive Events on Children" by Florencia Torche, Jason Fletcher, and Jennie E. Brand explores the varying impacts of disruptive events such as economic recessions, natural disasters, job loss, and divorce on children. These events can have long-lasting effects on children's academic achievement, socioemotional well-being, health, and future socioeconomic status. The authors highlight that while these events are prevalent among American families, their consequences differ across various groups. The same event may have profound negative impacts on some groups, minor or no impact on others, and even positive effects on some groups.
The article discusses two main theoretical approaches to understanding these variations: the resource disparities approach and the normativity and predictability approach. The resource disparities approach focuses on the socioeconomic resources available to families, suggesting that disadvantaged families are more vulnerable to the negative consequences of disruptions due to limited resources. In contrast, the normativity and predictability approach considers the social context and the likelihood of experiencing disruptive events, arguing that events that are more normative or predictable may have less severe impacts on advantaged groups.
Methodologically, the authors address the challenges of identifying and estimating causal effects, including confounding and reverse causality. They emphasize the importance of controlling for confounding factors and using econometric tools to reduce bias. The article also discusses the selection of domains for heterogeneity analysis, the use of machine learning to uncover patterns of variation, and the need to consider differential selection and treatment conditions.
The article reviews the impact of disruptive events across several domains: economic, household and family, education, health, and environmental. For example, job loss can lead to economic shocks, psychological distress, and social relationships disruptions, affecting children's well-being and outcomes. Economic recessions can negatively impact children's psychological health and education, while home loss through foreclosure or eviction can lead to mental health issues and financial instability.
Overall, the article provides a comprehensive framework for understanding the disparate effects of disruptive events on children and highlights the need for nuanced research methods to capture these variations.The article "Disparate Effects of Disruptive Events on Children" by Florencia Torche, Jason Fletcher, and Jennie E. Brand explores the varying impacts of disruptive events such as economic recessions, natural disasters, job loss, and divorce on children. These events can have long-lasting effects on children's academic achievement, socioemotional well-being, health, and future socioeconomic status. The authors highlight that while these events are prevalent among American families, their consequences differ across various groups. The same event may have profound negative impacts on some groups, minor or no impact on others, and even positive effects on some groups.
The article discusses two main theoretical approaches to understanding these variations: the resource disparities approach and the normativity and predictability approach. The resource disparities approach focuses on the socioeconomic resources available to families, suggesting that disadvantaged families are more vulnerable to the negative consequences of disruptions due to limited resources. In contrast, the normativity and predictability approach considers the social context and the likelihood of experiencing disruptive events, arguing that events that are more normative or predictable may have less severe impacts on advantaged groups.
Methodologically, the authors address the challenges of identifying and estimating causal effects, including confounding and reverse causality. They emphasize the importance of controlling for confounding factors and using econometric tools to reduce bias. The article also discusses the selection of domains for heterogeneity analysis, the use of machine learning to uncover patterns of variation, and the need to consider differential selection and treatment conditions.
The article reviews the impact of disruptive events across several domains: economic, household and family, education, health, and environmental. For example, job loss can lead to economic shocks, psychological distress, and social relationships disruptions, affecting children's well-being and outcomes. Economic recessions can negatively impact children's psychological health and education, while home loss through foreclosure or eviction can lead to mental health issues and financial instability.
Overall, the article provides a comprehensive framework for understanding the disparate effects of disruptive events on children and highlights the need for nuanced research methods to capture these variations.