Facing Up to the Problem of Consciousness

Facing Up to the Problem of Consciousness

1995 | David J. Chalmers
David J. Chalmers' paper "Facing Up to the Problem of Consciousness" addresses the most challenging aspect of understanding the mind: consciousness. He distinguishes between "easy" and "hard" problems of consciousness, where the easy problems are those that can be explained using cognitive science and neuroscience, such as discrimination, categorization, and verbal reportability. The hard problem, however, is the subjective aspect of experience, which is resistant to explanation by these methods. Chalmers critiques recent reductive approaches to consciousness, arguing that they fail to address the core issue of why physical processes give rise to subjective experience. He suggests that a nonreductive approach is necessary, where consciousness is treated as a fundamental feature of the world, alongside physical properties like mass and charge. This naturalistic dualism aims to bridge the explanatory gap between physical processes and experience by postulating psychophysical principles that connect the two. Chalmers outlines a candidate theory of consciousness based on principles of structural coherence and organizational invariance, as well as a double-aspect view of information. He emphasizes the importance of philosophical analysis, thought experiments, and nonempirical constraints like simplicity and coherence in developing a theory. Despite the challenges, Chalmers believes that progress is possible and encourages researchers to explore nonreductive explanations for consciousness.David J. Chalmers' paper "Facing Up to the Problem of Consciousness" addresses the most challenging aspect of understanding the mind: consciousness. He distinguishes between "easy" and "hard" problems of consciousness, where the easy problems are those that can be explained using cognitive science and neuroscience, such as discrimination, categorization, and verbal reportability. The hard problem, however, is the subjective aspect of experience, which is resistant to explanation by these methods. Chalmers critiques recent reductive approaches to consciousness, arguing that they fail to address the core issue of why physical processes give rise to subjective experience. He suggests that a nonreductive approach is necessary, where consciousness is treated as a fundamental feature of the world, alongside physical properties like mass and charge. This naturalistic dualism aims to bridge the explanatory gap between physical processes and experience by postulating psychophysical principles that connect the two. Chalmers outlines a candidate theory of consciousness based on principles of structural coherence and organizational invariance, as well as a double-aspect view of information. He emphasizes the importance of philosophical analysis, thought experiments, and nonempirical constraints like simplicity and coherence in developing a theory. Despite the challenges, Chalmers believes that progress is possible and encourages researchers to explore nonreductive explanations for consciousness.
Reach us at info@study.space