8 (3): 342-348, jul/set, 1992 | Maria Cecília de Souza Minayo
The book "O Desafio do Conhecimento — Pesquisa Qualitativa em Saúde" by Maria Cecília de Souza Minayo is a comprehensive analysis of theoretical and methodological approaches in the social sciences, particularly in the area of medicine and health. The author emphasizes qualitative research and the knowledge generated from field studies, addressing the importance of this approach in a context where traditional theoretical frameworks are crises and empirical approaches are impoverished.
The book is structured into an introduction, four chapters, and a conclusion. It begins by critiquing positivism and comprehensive sociology, favoring the Marxist dialectic for its ability to encompass both objective and subjective aspects of reality. The author then focuses on the field of health, highlighting its relationship with broader economic, political, and social realities, including class, ideology, and modes of production.
The first chapter introduces the three major theoretical traditions—positivism, comprehensive sociology, and Marxist dialectics—and critiques their limitations. The second chapter discusses the operationalization of research concepts, emphasizing the convergence of multiple perspectives in scientific understanding. The third chapter delves into qualitative fieldwork techniques, such as observation and interviewing, and the importance of social representation. The fourth chapter focuses on the analysis of research materials, proposing methods like content analysis, discourse analysis, and hermeneutic-dialectical approaches.
The conclusion reiterates the historical and open-ended nature of social phenomena and the importance of a dialectical perspective in scientific methodology. The book is seen as a pioneering work in Brazilian social sciences, though it could have delved deeper into the political and practical dimensions of dialectics.
Marcos de S. Queiroz's "Representações sobre Saúde e Doença" (Representations of Health and Disease) is an anthropological study conducted in two working-class neighborhoods in Paulínia, Brazil, from 1988 to 1989. The book explores how the population and various health agents, including doctors, pharmacists, and nurses, perceive and manage health and illness. It also examines informal health practices influenced by religion, providing insights into the broader healthcare system as defined by Kleinman. The study contributes to understanding the socio-cultural construction of health and disease and the challenges faced during the implementation of the SUS (National Health System).The book "O Desafio do Conhecimento — Pesquisa Qualitativa em Saúde" by Maria Cecília de Souza Minayo is a comprehensive analysis of theoretical and methodological approaches in the social sciences, particularly in the area of medicine and health. The author emphasizes qualitative research and the knowledge generated from field studies, addressing the importance of this approach in a context where traditional theoretical frameworks are crises and empirical approaches are impoverished.
The book is structured into an introduction, four chapters, and a conclusion. It begins by critiquing positivism and comprehensive sociology, favoring the Marxist dialectic for its ability to encompass both objective and subjective aspects of reality. The author then focuses on the field of health, highlighting its relationship with broader economic, political, and social realities, including class, ideology, and modes of production.
The first chapter introduces the three major theoretical traditions—positivism, comprehensive sociology, and Marxist dialectics—and critiques their limitations. The second chapter discusses the operationalization of research concepts, emphasizing the convergence of multiple perspectives in scientific understanding. The third chapter delves into qualitative fieldwork techniques, such as observation and interviewing, and the importance of social representation. The fourth chapter focuses on the analysis of research materials, proposing methods like content analysis, discourse analysis, and hermeneutic-dialectical approaches.
The conclusion reiterates the historical and open-ended nature of social phenomena and the importance of a dialectical perspective in scientific methodology. The book is seen as a pioneering work in Brazilian social sciences, though it could have delved deeper into the political and practical dimensions of dialectics.
Marcos de S. Queiroz's "Representações sobre Saúde e Doença" (Representations of Health and Disease) is an anthropological study conducted in two working-class neighborhoods in Paulínia, Brazil, from 1988 to 1989. The book explores how the population and various health agents, including doctors, pharmacists, and nurses, perceive and manage health and illness. It also examines informal health practices influenced by religion, providing insights into the broader healthcare system as defined by Kleinman. The study contributes to understanding the socio-cultural construction of health and disease and the challenges faced during the implementation of the SUS (National Health System).