December 1978 | David J. Sahn, M.D., Anthony DeMaria, M.D., Joseph Kisslo, M.D., and Arthur Weyman, M.D.
A survey of 400 M-mode echocardiographic measurements was conducted to assess interobserver variability and determine the need for standardization. Of the 400 surveys, 76 were returned, allowing analysis of measurement consistency and criteria. The study found significant interobserver and interlaboratory variability in measurements, particularly for right ventricular structures. For example, the mean percent uncertainty for aortic root measurements was 13.8% using outer/inner dimensions and 24.2% using outer/outer dimensions. For right ventricular cavity and anterior wall measurements, uncertainties ranged from 40–70%. Left ventricular measurements showed lower uncertainty (10–25%). The study emphasized the need for standardization of measurement criteria to improve reproducibility and clinical utility.
The survey included five M-mode echocardiograms with calibration markers, measured by participants. The results showed that 33% of examiners measured the aorta as outer/inner or leading edge dimensions, while 20% used outer/outer dimensions. For the left atrium, 64% excluded the aortic wall, while 34% included it. Right ventricular wall measurements were challenging, with only 33% of examiners attempting to measure it. The study also found that 33% of examiners measured the right ventricular cavity at the peak of the R wave, while 33% measured it at the onset of the QRS.
The study recommended standardized measurement criteria for M-mode echocardiography, including measuring the aortic root using the leading edge method, measuring the left atrium at end-ventricular systole, and measuring end-diastole at the onset of the QRS complex. The recommendations also emphasized the importance of measuring cavities and walls at the level of the mitral valve leaflets or chordae, depending on the patient's age. The study concluded that standardization of measurement criteria is essential to improve the accuracy and reproducibility of M-mode echocardiographic measurements.A survey of 400 M-mode echocardiographic measurements was conducted to assess interobserver variability and determine the need for standardization. Of the 400 surveys, 76 were returned, allowing analysis of measurement consistency and criteria. The study found significant interobserver and interlaboratory variability in measurements, particularly for right ventricular structures. For example, the mean percent uncertainty for aortic root measurements was 13.8% using outer/inner dimensions and 24.2% using outer/outer dimensions. For right ventricular cavity and anterior wall measurements, uncertainties ranged from 40–70%. Left ventricular measurements showed lower uncertainty (10–25%). The study emphasized the need for standardization of measurement criteria to improve reproducibility and clinical utility.
The survey included five M-mode echocardiograms with calibration markers, measured by participants. The results showed that 33% of examiners measured the aorta as outer/inner or leading edge dimensions, while 20% used outer/outer dimensions. For the left atrium, 64% excluded the aortic wall, while 34% included it. Right ventricular wall measurements were challenging, with only 33% of examiners attempting to measure it. The study also found that 33% of examiners measured the right ventricular cavity at the peak of the R wave, while 33% measured it at the onset of the QRS.
The study recommended standardized measurement criteria for M-mode echocardiography, including measuring the aortic root using the leading edge method, measuring the left atrium at end-ventricular systole, and measuring end-diastole at the onset of the QRS complex. The recommendations also emphasized the importance of measuring cavities and walls at the level of the mitral valve leaflets or chordae, depending on the patient's age. The study concluded that standardization of measurement criteria is essential to improve the accuracy and reproducibility of M-mode echocardiographic measurements.