Robert J. Shiller, a professor at Yale University, explores the role of social dynamics in stock prices, arguing that speculative asset prices are influenced by social movements and fashions, similar to other areas of public opinion. He challenges the traditional efficient markets hypothesis, which assumes that prices reflect all available information and that market psychology is irrelevant. Shiller points out that while academic research on market psychology declined in the 1950s, recent literature in finance and macroeconomics has largely focused on rational expectations and efficient markets. However, Shiller argues that social psychology may be a more significant factor in financial markets than previously thought.
Shiller discusses how social movements can influence investment behavior, citing examples from everyday life, such as changes in fashion, politics, and health trends. He notes that attitudes toward investments vary across cultures and over time, suggesting that social factors play a crucial role in shaping investment decisions. He also highlights the importance of understanding the behavior of institutional and individual investors, noting that while institutional investors hold a growing share of stocks, most corporate stock is still owned by wealthy individuals who may not be fully rational in their investment decisions.
Shiller argues that stock prices are not solely determined by fundamental values but are also influenced by social psychology, including herd behavior, group pressure, and the diffusion of opinions. He presents an alternative model where smart-money investors, who respond to public information, interact with ordinary investors who may be influenced by fads or emotions. This model suggests that stock prices can fluctuate due to the interplay between rational and irrational behavior.
Shiller also examines historical data on stock market trends, noting that the postwar bull market was characterized by a surge in participation and interest in the stock market, which may have been driven by social movements rather than purely rational expectations. He challenges the efficient markets hypothesis by pointing out that while stock returns are not highly predictable, this does not necessarily mean that market psychology is irrelevant. Instead, he argues that social factors can significantly influence stock prices, and that the efficient markets model may not fully capture the complexity of financial markets.
Shiller concludes that social psychology plays a major role in financial markets, and that the efficient markets hypothesis may be incomplete in its assumptions. He emphasizes the need for further research into the role of social dynamics in shaping stock prices and investment behavior.Robert J. Shiller, a professor at Yale University, explores the role of social dynamics in stock prices, arguing that speculative asset prices are influenced by social movements and fashions, similar to other areas of public opinion. He challenges the traditional efficient markets hypothesis, which assumes that prices reflect all available information and that market psychology is irrelevant. Shiller points out that while academic research on market psychology declined in the 1950s, recent literature in finance and macroeconomics has largely focused on rational expectations and efficient markets. However, Shiller argues that social psychology may be a more significant factor in financial markets than previously thought.
Shiller discusses how social movements can influence investment behavior, citing examples from everyday life, such as changes in fashion, politics, and health trends. He notes that attitudes toward investments vary across cultures and over time, suggesting that social factors play a crucial role in shaping investment decisions. He also highlights the importance of understanding the behavior of institutional and individual investors, noting that while institutional investors hold a growing share of stocks, most corporate stock is still owned by wealthy individuals who may not be fully rational in their investment decisions.
Shiller argues that stock prices are not solely determined by fundamental values but are also influenced by social psychology, including herd behavior, group pressure, and the diffusion of opinions. He presents an alternative model where smart-money investors, who respond to public information, interact with ordinary investors who may be influenced by fads or emotions. This model suggests that stock prices can fluctuate due to the interplay between rational and irrational behavior.
Shiller also examines historical data on stock market trends, noting that the postwar bull market was characterized by a surge in participation and interest in the stock market, which may have been driven by social movements rather than purely rational expectations. He challenges the efficient markets hypothesis by pointing out that while stock returns are not highly predictable, this does not necessarily mean that market psychology is irrelevant. Instead, he argues that social factors can significantly influence stock prices, and that the efficient markets model may not fully capture the complexity of financial markets.
Shiller concludes that social psychology plays a major role in financial markets, and that the efficient markets hypothesis may be incomplete in its assumptions. He emphasizes the need for further research into the role of social dynamics in shaping stock prices and investment behavior.