The Discipline and Practice of Qualitative Research

The Discipline and Practice of Qualitative Research

2005 | Norman K. Denzin and Yvonna S. Lincoln
Qualitative research is a complex field with a long and contested history, deeply intertwined with colonialism and its legacy. Linda Tuhiwai Smith highlights that the term "research" is linked to European imperialism and colonialism, and is often seen as a dirty word in indigenous contexts. Qualitative research, including observation, participation, interviewing, and ethnography, has historically served as a metaphor for colonial knowledge, power, and truth. This is because research, both quantitative and qualitative, is scientific and provides a foundation for representing "the Other." Colonial powers used qualitative research to study and control foreign, deviant, or troublesome groups, leading to its association with colonialism. Qualitative research in sociology and anthropology emerged from a desire to understand the "other," often a non-white, foreign, or primitive person. This research was initially driven by colonial interests, and as a result, it became entangled with racist projects. The field has evolved through several historical moments, including the traditional (1900–1950), modernist (1950–1970), blurred genres (1970–1986), crisis of representation (1986–1990), postmodern (1990–1995), postexperimental (1995–2000), methodologically contested present (2000–2004), and fractured future (2005–). Each of these moments reflects different epistemological and methodological approaches, with qualitative research often emphasizing interpretive, naturalistic, and situated practices. Qualitative research is interdisciplinary and involves a wide range of methods, including case studies, interviews, participant observation, and visual methods. It is characterized by its focus on meaning, context, and the lived experiences of individuals. The qualitative researcher is often described as a bricoleur, someone who draws on multiple disciplines and methods to create a holistic understanding of a subject. This approach is often compared to quilting, montage, and jazz improvisation, where different elements are combined to create a new, meaningful whole. Qualitative research is also deeply political and ethical, often challenging dominant paradigms and power structures. It is concerned with issues of race, gender, class, and democracy, and seeks to give voice to marginalized communities. The field is in tension with positivist and postpositivist approaches, which emphasize measurement and quantification. Qualitative research, in contrast, emphasizes the value of subjective, interpretive, and contextual understanding. The field of qualitative research is also in tension with the SBR (scientific-based research) movement, which promotes a narrow, evidence-based, and quantitative approach to research. This movement has created a hostile political environment for qualitative research, often dismissing it as unscientific or subjective. However, qualitative researchers argue that their methods are essential for understanding complex, lived experiences and for challenging dominant narratives. In conclusion,Qualitative research is a complex field with a long and contested history, deeply intertwined with colonialism and its legacy. Linda Tuhiwai Smith highlights that the term "research" is linked to European imperialism and colonialism, and is often seen as a dirty word in indigenous contexts. Qualitative research, including observation, participation, interviewing, and ethnography, has historically served as a metaphor for colonial knowledge, power, and truth. This is because research, both quantitative and qualitative, is scientific and provides a foundation for representing "the Other." Colonial powers used qualitative research to study and control foreign, deviant, or troublesome groups, leading to its association with colonialism. Qualitative research in sociology and anthropology emerged from a desire to understand the "other," often a non-white, foreign, or primitive person. This research was initially driven by colonial interests, and as a result, it became entangled with racist projects. The field has evolved through several historical moments, including the traditional (1900–1950), modernist (1950–1970), blurred genres (1970–1986), crisis of representation (1986–1990), postmodern (1990–1995), postexperimental (1995–2000), methodologically contested present (2000–2004), and fractured future (2005–). Each of these moments reflects different epistemological and methodological approaches, with qualitative research often emphasizing interpretive, naturalistic, and situated practices. Qualitative research is interdisciplinary and involves a wide range of methods, including case studies, interviews, participant observation, and visual methods. It is characterized by its focus on meaning, context, and the lived experiences of individuals. The qualitative researcher is often described as a bricoleur, someone who draws on multiple disciplines and methods to create a holistic understanding of a subject. This approach is often compared to quilting, montage, and jazz improvisation, where different elements are combined to create a new, meaningful whole. Qualitative research is also deeply political and ethical, often challenging dominant paradigms and power structures. It is concerned with issues of race, gender, class, and democracy, and seeks to give voice to marginalized communities. The field is in tension with positivist and postpositivist approaches, which emphasize measurement and quantification. Qualitative research, in contrast, emphasizes the value of subjective, interpretive, and contextual understanding. The field of qualitative research is also in tension with the SBR (scientific-based research) movement, which promotes a narrow, evidence-based, and quantitative approach to research. This movement has created a hostile political environment for qualitative research, often dismissing it as unscientific or subjective. However, qualitative researchers argue that their methods are essential for understanding complex, lived experiences and for challenging dominant narratives. In conclusion,
Reach us at info@study.space
Understanding The Discipline and Practice of Qualitative Research