The article "The Globalization of Liberalization: Policy Diffusion in the International Political Economy" by Beth A. Simmons and Zachary Elkins explores the spread of liberal economic policies and ideas globally over the past three decades. The authors argue that the adoption of these policies is not solely influenced by domestic factors but is also shaped by international processes, particularly policy diffusion. They hypothesize that policy diffusion occurs through two main mechanisms: altered payoffs and channeled learning.
1. **Altered Payoffs**: This mechanism suggests that the policy decisions of one country can alter the costs and benefits for others. For example, if a country liberalizes its capital account, it may attract more investment and trade, leading neighboring countries to feel competitive pressures to match these policies. Additionally, changes in global norms and reputational payoffs can influence policy choices. For instance, adopting policies that align with a neoliberal consensus can enhance a country's legitimacy and reputation.
2. **Channeled Learning**: This mechanism posits that governments learn from the experiences of other countries, either by following successful models or through communication networks. Successful economic policies, such as those seen in Japan and Chile, can serve as templates for other countries. Communication networks, including intergovernmental meetings and private business contacts, can also transmit information about effective policies. Cultural similarity is another factor, as policies of culturally similar countries are perceived as more relevant and applicable.
The authors use data from the International Monetary Fund (IMF) to analyze transitions in three key policy areas: capital account openness, current account openness, and exchange rate unification. They employ spatial econometric models to account for the spatial clustering of policy changes and control for various economic shocks and other factors. The findings suggest that policy diffusion plays a significant role in shaping economic policies, highlighting the importance of international interactions and cultural influences in the global political economy.The article "The Globalization of Liberalization: Policy Diffusion in the International Political Economy" by Beth A. Simmons and Zachary Elkins explores the spread of liberal economic policies and ideas globally over the past three decades. The authors argue that the adoption of these policies is not solely influenced by domestic factors but is also shaped by international processes, particularly policy diffusion. They hypothesize that policy diffusion occurs through two main mechanisms: altered payoffs and channeled learning.
1. **Altered Payoffs**: This mechanism suggests that the policy decisions of one country can alter the costs and benefits for others. For example, if a country liberalizes its capital account, it may attract more investment and trade, leading neighboring countries to feel competitive pressures to match these policies. Additionally, changes in global norms and reputational payoffs can influence policy choices. For instance, adopting policies that align with a neoliberal consensus can enhance a country's legitimacy and reputation.
2. **Channeled Learning**: This mechanism posits that governments learn from the experiences of other countries, either by following successful models or through communication networks. Successful economic policies, such as those seen in Japan and Chile, can serve as templates for other countries. Communication networks, including intergovernmental meetings and private business contacts, can also transmit information about effective policies. Cultural similarity is another factor, as policies of culturally similar countries are perceived as more relevant and applicable.
The authors use data from the International Monetary Fund (IMF) to analyze transitions in three key policy areas: capital account openness, current account openness, and exchange rate unification. They employ spatial econometric models to account for the spatial clustering of policy changes and control for various economic shocks and other factors. The findings suggest that policy diffusion plays a significant role in shaping economic policies, highlighting the importance of international interactions and cultural influences in the global political economy.