The Cathedral and the Bazaar

The Cathedral and the Bazaar

Fall 1999 | Eric Raymond
In "The Cathedral and the Bazaar," Eric Raymond analyzes the success of the open-source project fetchmail, testing theories about software engineering inspired by Linux's history. He contrasts two development models: the "cathedral" model, typical of the commercial world, and the "bazaar" model of the Linux world. These models stem from differing assumptions about software debugging. Raymond argues that "given enough eyeballs, all bugs are shallow," suggesting that open, collaborative systems can self-correct effectively. He draws analogies to other self-correcting systems of selfish agents, highlighting the Linux experience's implications for software development. Raymond was initially skeptical of Linux, believing that complex software needed centralized, carefully crafted development, like a cathedral. However, Linux's development style—release early and often, delegate tasks, and be open—surprised him. The Linux community, resembling a "bazaar" of diverse approaches, produced a coherent and stable system through collaboration. Raymond tested his theory by running an open-source project in the bazaar style, which was successful. Raymond had been involved in open-source development for years, but Linux challenged his beliefs. He cofounded a small ISP, CCIL, where he used the internet extensively. He needed a program to deliver email to his machine, leading him to develop fetchmail. This experience reinforced his belief in the power of open collaboration. Raymond concludes that the Linux community's success stems from its open, collaborative nature, which can be applied to other open-source projects. He suggests that understanding this model can help developers create better software and be more productive.In "The Cathedral and the Bazaar," Eric Raymond analyzes the success of the open-source project fetchmail, testing theories about software engineering inspired by Linux's history. He contrasts two development models: the "cathedral" model, typical of the commercial world, and the "bazaar" model of the Linux world. These models stem from differing assumptions about software debugging. Raymond argues that "given enough eyeballs, all bugs are shallow," suggesting that open, collaborative systems can self-correct effectively. He draws analogies to other self-correcting systems of selfish agents, highlighting the Linux experience's implications for software development. Raymond was initially skeptical of Linux, believing that complex software needed centralized, carefully crafted development, like a cathedral. However, Linux's development style—release early and often, delegate tasks, and be open—surprised him. The Linux community, resembling a "bazaar" of diverse approaches, produced a coherent and stable system through collaboration. Raymond tested his theory by running an open-source project in the bazaar style, which was successful. Raymond had been involved in open-source development for years, but Linux challenged his beliefs. He cofounded a small ISP, CCIL, where he used the internet extensively. He needed a program to deliver email to his machine, leading him to develop fetchmail. This experience reinforced his belief in the power of open collaboration. Raymond concludes that the Linux community's success stems from its open, collaborative nature, which can be applied to other open-source projects. He suggests that understanding this model can help developers create better software and be more productive.
Reach us at info@study.space
[slides] The cathedral and the bazaar | StudySpace