The book "The Social Transformation of American Medicine" by Paul Starr is a comprehensive and ambitious study that explores the evolution of the American medical profession and the transformation of medical care into a vast industry. Starr, a young sociologist at Harvard, combines social history, political science, and journalism to provide a sociological perspective on these changes. The book is divided into two main parts: the first focuses on the rise of the sovereign medical profession, detailing how physicians gained cultural authority and control over health-related matters; the second part examines the struggle for medical care, discussing the increasing corporatization and state involvement in the medical industry.
Starr highlights the dramatic transformation of the medical profession from a frail and insecure entity to a powerful and unified force, and how this authority enabled them to resist organizational pressures and maintain control. However, the book overlooks important aspects such as the social determination of medical knowledge, the role of medicalization and demedicalization, and the intellectual and conceptual underpinnings of medical practice. Despite these limitations, the book is highly acclaimed for its insights into the history and future of American medicine, and it is expected to provoke reflection and further discussion on the topic.The book "The Social Transformation of American Medicine" by Paul Starr is a comprehensive and ambitious study that explores the evolution of the American medical profession and the transformation of medical care into a vast industry. Starr, a young sociologist at Harvard, combines social history, political science, and journalism to provide a sociological perspective on these changes. The book is divided into two main parts: the first focuses on the rise of the sovereign medical profession, detailing how physicians gained cultural authority and control over health-related matters; the second part examines the struggle for medical care, discussing the increasing corporatization and state involvement in the medical industry.
Starr highlights the dramatic transformation of the medical profession from a frail and insecure entity to a powerful and unified force, and how this authority enabled them to resist organizational pressures and maintain control. However, the book overlooks important aspects such as the social determination of medical knowledge, the role of medicalization and demedicalization, and the intellectual and conceptual underpinnings of medical practice. Despite these limitations, the book is highly acclaimed for its insights into the history and future of American medicine, and it is expected to provoke reflection and further discussion on the topic.