July 2024 | MALINDA DILHARA, University of Colorado, USA; ABHIRAM BELLUR, University of Colorado, USA; TIMOFEY BRYKSN, JetBrains Research, Cyprus; DANNY DIG, JetBrains Research, University of Colorado, USA
The paper "Unprecedented Code Change Automation: The Fusion of LLMs and Transformation by Example" by Malinda Dilhara, Abhiram Bellur, Timofey Bryksin, and Danny Dig explores the automation of repetitive code changes, known as "code change patterns" (CPATs), in software development. The authors highlight the limitations of current Transformation by Example (TBE) techniques, which are constrained by the quality and quantity of input examples, and propose a novel approach that leverages Large Language Models (LLMs) to generate semantically equivalent but previously unseen variants of CPATs. This approach significantly enhances the effectiveness of TBE systems.
The paper outlines the development and evaluation of PyCraft, a tool that combines static and dynamic analysis with LLM capabilities to automate code changes. PyCraft generates code variants that meet three criteria: correctness (semantic equivalence), usefulness (reflecting typical developer practices), and applicability (aligning with the original CPAT's intent). The tool uses chain-of-thought reasoning to generate variations and comprehensive test cases, achieving an F-measure of 96.6% in identifying correct variations.
The authors conducted a comprehensive evaluation of PyCraft, demonstrating its ability to generate up to 584 raw variations per CPAT, with an average of 58 applicable variants. These variations were submitted to highly-rated projects, with 83% of the 86 CPAT instances accepted and merged through 44 pull requests, validating the practical value of the generated changes.
Key contributions of the paper include:
1. A novel approach using LLMs to generate unseen variants for CPATs.
2. Best practices for using LLMs to generate code variations and test cases.
3. The design, implementation, and evaluation of PyCraft, including a performance evaluation and qualitative analysis.
4. An open-source tool and evaluation dataset for reuse.
The paper also discusses the challenges faced by existing TBE techniques and how PyCraft addresses them, particularly in handling complex coding idioms and unseen variations. The evaluation results show that PyCraft outperforms previous state-of-the-art tools in generating and applying transformations, significantly enhancing the automation of code changes.The paper "Unprecedented Code Change Automation: The Fusion of LLMs and Transformation by Example" by Malinda Dilhara, Abhiram Bellur, Timofey Bryksin, and Danny Dig explores the automation of repetitive code changes, known as "code change patterns" (CPATs), in software development. The authors highlight the limitations of current Transformation by Example (TBE) techniques, which are constrained by the quality and quantity of input examples, and propose a novel approach that leverages Large Language Models (LLMs) to generate semantically equivalent but previously unseen variants of CPATs. This approach significantly enhances the effectiveness of TBE systems.
The paper outlines the development and evaluation of PyCraft, a tool that combines static and dynamic analysis with LLM capabilities to automate code changes. PyCraft generates code variants that meet three criteria: correctness (semantic equivalence), usefulness (reflecting typical developer practices), and applicability (aligning with the original CPAT's intent). The tool uses chain-of-thought reasoning to generate variations and comprehensive test cases, achieving an F-measure of 96.6% in identifying correct variations.
The authors conducted a comprehensive evaluation of PyCraft, demonstrating its ability to generate up to 584 raw variations per CPAT, with an average of 58 applicable variants. These variations were submitted to highly-rated projects, with 83% of the 86 CPAT instances accepted and merged through 44 pull requests, validating the practical value of the generated changes.
Key contributions of the paper include:
1. A novel approach using LLMs to generate unseen variants for CPATs.
2. Best practices for using LLMs to generate code variations and test cases.
3. The design, implementation, and evaluation of PyCraft, including a performance evaluation and qualitative analysis.
4. An open-source tool and evaluation dataset for reuse.
The paper also discusses the challenges faced by existing TBE techniques and how PyCraft addresses them, particularly in handling complex coding idioms and unseen variations. The evaluation results show that PyCraft outperforms previous state-of-the-art tools in generating and applying transformations, significantly enhancing the automation of code changes.